Ozersky: I see the Best of New York just came out. Do you really stand behind your picks? Are they really the "best"?
Platt: You know my position on passing absolute judgments, especially about food. It's a very subjective situation, and all you can do is give an informed opinion. Thats all Best of New York is. I will say that there were a few things I would have liked to include. There was a superb short rib at a restaurant in Brooklyn called Moimthat I would have liked to write up. There's also a great crispy chicken dish in Brooklyn at a place called Lucky 8 that the editors considered a little too obscure. As a rule, though, I like reading the issue more than writing it.
Ozersky: Me too, except for one thing. I have to say that I was a little disappointed that there was no best burger in this issue. I thought your best un-beef burger was a cop-out. What is your favorite burger? Do you have one? Just cough it up, already!
Platt: My favorite burger is Shake Shack. No contest.
Ozersky: What about the contest for best ramen? Was your winner, Setagaya, neck and neck with Momofuku?
Platt: Well, Momofuku isn't really a ramen bar, is it. Setagaya's the real thing, straight from Tokyo, complete with towel-headed ramen ninjas behind the bar, and legions of faithful ramen geeks slurping down bowls of that delicious "shio ramen."
Ozersky: But does that mean their soup is better? What do I care if it's more authentic?
Platt: Yes, that means the broth is better. What do you know about ramen, Mr. Pork Chop?!?
Ozersky: What do you think the broth is made of? Speaking of pork, I had to wonder at you picking Adour. In a city with so much great bacon, sausage, char siu, chops, and all the rest, I find it hard to believe that ultrarefined number there could be the best.
Platt: It's a matter of taste, Cutty! The Adour dish combines all the thing you pork fiends crave: artisanal flavor, good old-time fattiness (there's a little stamp of candied belly on the side), and a wheel of loose, handmade boudin noir thrown in.
Ozersky: I'm glad I didn't have to write that one. I think my brain would have exploded. I'm glad, too, that I didn't have to do the lasagne category. Marco's is fantastic, but so is the mushroom-driven version at Fiamma.
Platt: I didn't like the Fiamma lasagne much. I dimly recall it being sludgy and brown and weirdly sweet. In my humble opinion, the lasagne verdi at Insieme is a more faithful gourmet iteration of this great family dish.
Ozersky: What about the part where you pick your favorite new restaurant? Did you and Gail and the Robs divvy that up? Was Dovetail your real pick, or did you cede another place to one of them?
Platt: It does sound like we divvied them up, but Dovetail was my real pick. I liked the unlikely location, and the range of the cooking. Also it's the last good restaurant I've dined at. After a month or two my memory fades.
Most Viewed Stories
Baby, It’s Cold: 12 Advanced Hot Chocolates You Should Drink Today
Via Carota Now Serving Stupendously Good Bunless Burgers on Grove Street
Nestlé Is Developing a Diet Drink That Burns Fat Without Cardio
IHOP Blew Up Twitter With This Dumb Tweet
Starbucks Adds Wireless Charging, Because Stores Aren’t Crowded Enough Already
Via Carota Now Serving Stupendously Good Bunless Burgers on Grove StreetAll openings »
Franny’s Offshoot Marco’s Will Close Next MonthAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Stories Elsewhere You Might Like
Beloved Cookbook Destination Bonnie Slotnick Is the Latest Victim of Rising Rents
Restaurant Review: Dirty French Is Uneven, But Generally Pleasurable
Underwest Donuts Will Serve Its Sinkers Inside a West Side Highway Car Wash
How to Host the Most Glorious Friendsgiving!
powered by PubExchange
Latest News on Grub StreetRevered Chef Daniel Patterson Will Refuse Tips at His Next Restaurant
"That thing on the menu costs $25. That's all it costs."New York Times Agrees to Stop Trolling Minnesota With Its Ridiculous Grape Salad Recipe
The paper admits it may have missed the mark this time.Guy Fieri Rocked a Very Real Mullet As Recently As 2000
It's exactly the #tbt tweet you expected.Franny’s Offshoot Marco’s Will Close Next Month
The restaurant simply didn't make enough money.A Café Unwisely Told Moms to Go Breast-feed in the Bathroom
It said it had "a chair nearby which can be taken inside" for convenience.Brooklyn Versus the Drunk Idiots
Even Roberta's took a stand against SantaCon.Via Carota Now Serving Stupendously Good Bunless Burgers on Grove Street
"No bun because bread is boring."Animal-Rights Group Says It Can Prove Chick-fil-A Uses an Abusive Chicken Supplier
Though the chain says it no longer has a connection.Baby, It’s Cold: 12 Advanced Hot Chocolates You Should Drink Today
Spiked with lavender, caramel, brownie batter, and booze.Bonnie Slotnick on the Struggle to Save Her Cherished Cookbook Shop
"I am the store and the store is me."
Housemade charcuterie, whole rotisserie chicken, and more.Nestlé Is Developing a Diet Drink That Burns Fat Without Cardio
Instead of a 20-minute jog, how about cardio in a can?Get Ready for Pie-Flavored Whiskey
Even though it's not actually possible to ever really be ready for pie-flavored whiskey.A Restaurant Discriminated Against One of Its Servers for Not Going to Church
It turns out, however, the owner just disapproved of his son's choice of date.MasterChef Junior Recap: Meet Gordon Ramsay’s Mum
And see what happens when kids get strapped together while baking cupcakes.Meet the Woman Who Just Might Restore Your Faith in Granola
She meticulously sources each and every ingredient.Barack Obama’s Restaurant-Review-Show Appearance From 2001 Is Pretty Great
"The prices are right, and the portions are good," he says, diplomatically.Starbucks Adds Wireless Charging, Because Stores Aren’t Crowded Enough Already
The first 1,500 spots rolled out yesterday at 200 Bay Area stores.Some Diner Customers Called Their Waiter a Gay Slur on Their Receipt
And a manager allegedly apologized to the customers about it.Sustainable Salad Chainlet Sweetgreen Raised $18.5 Million for Expansion
Danny Meyer and Daniel Boulud are getting behind it.
It's dressed up like a feather boa and tastes like a dream.IHOP Blew Up Twitter With This Dumb Tweet
Ban all corporate food Twitter accounts.The Alinea Team Hired a Google Engineer to Beef Up Its Ticketing System
Nick Kokonas says all the details on the new company are yet to be announced.Restaurant Will Pay $28K Fine After Knowingly Serving Whale Meat
The makers of The Cove helped undercover agents order the sushi back in 2010.Morgenstern’s Unveils New Pies Just in Time for Thanksgiving
How about a slice of salted-caramel custard with pretzel crust?This Thanksgiving Kickstarter for a Bacon-Wrapped Gator Stuffed With a Turducken Needs Your Help
$5,000 in six hours, to be precise.The Tiny Hamster Thanksgiving Video Is Everything Right About America
Right down to the tiny pumpkin pies.Disappearing Acts: An Afternoon With the Magicians of Café Edison
"When, exactly, was the last time you had your mind read?"A Lot of Heston Blumenthal’s Fat Duck Pop-up Seats Are Going to Scammers
The chef has a Taylor Swift-size scalping problem.Beloved Cookbook Destination Bonnie Slotnick Is the Latest Victim of Rising Rents
The shop's proprietor says she is determined to reopen elsewhere.
“You come here and see this chicken was walking around half an hour ago, you are going to make sure you don’t mess it up. It resensitizes people.”Get Ready for Scrapple-Flavored Beer
Dogfish Head is offering reckless drinkers a draft-only stout made with pork mush.Even McDonald’s Won’t Use GMO Potatoes
You can pry their French fry baskets from their cold, dead, GMO-free hands.Shake Shack Teams Up With Big Gay Ice Cream for Limited-Edition Layer Shakes
Yes, eggnog soft-serve.Rick Bayless and Alex Stupak on Getting Diners to Embrace the Complexities of Mexican Cooking
"We're starting to see that the population is catching up."Watch This Italian Chef Hilariously Garble the Word Worcestershire
"Woo-stu-shoo-shur."Someone Finally Combined the Best Parts of a Bánh Mì and a Cuban Sandwich
Nicely done, Num Pang.Hellmann’s Continues Fight Against Vegan ‘Mayo’ Maker With Sneaky Website Edits
Let the condiment conspiracy theories begin.Why Does Con Ed Hate Ramen Shops?
No one is cooking with gas.A Rival Chef Sabotaged Gordon Ramsay’s New Restaurant With Tons of Fake Reservations
Heddon Street Kitchen had 100 no-shows for 140 tables.
Mario Carbone, Marc Forgione, Amanda Cohen, Kevin Pemouile, too, and that's just the beginning.What to Eat at the First New York Location of Lyfe Kitchen
Healthy fast food, with a menu devised by Oprah Winfrey’s former personal chef.Restaurant Review: Dirty French Is Uneven, But Generally Pleasurable
The red-sauce enthusiasts behind Carbone and Parm go Gallic.This Hops Machine Makes Crappy Beer Taste Awesome
Craft brewers should maybe be afraid.Classic and Contemporary Takes on 11 Favorites of the New York Kitchen
All of them, we’d wager, would pass muster with the most discriminating grandma as well as a Smorgasburg-crazed 20-something.McDonald’s Invented Bubblegum-Flavored Broccoli
It was nixed from the menu because it confused everyone.Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Broth, a New Burger, and Lots and Lots of Dumplings
Find out where to eat in our weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.Inside an Uptown Dinner Party at Christophe de Menil’s Home
Nantucket bay scallops for 25, prepared by Canard, Inc.Curtis Duffy on Being the World’s Newest Michelin Three-Star Chef
Chicago's Grace is the latest restaurant to receive the honor.35 Next-Level Holiday Delivery Options That Throw Your Party for You
Simply pick up the phone.