Ozersky: I see the Best of New York just came out. Do you really stand behind your picks? Are they really the "best"?
Platt: You know my position on passing absolute judgments, especially about food. It's a very subjective situation, and all you can do is give an informed opinion. That’s all Best of New York is. I will say that there were a few things I would have liked to include. There was a superb short rib at a restaurant in Brooklyn called Moimthat I would have liked to write up. There's also a great crispy chicken dish in Brooklyn at a place called Lucky 8 that the editors considered a little too obscure. As a rule, though, I like reading the issue more than writing it.
Ozersky: Me too, except for one thing. I have to say that I was a little disappointed that there was no best burger in this issue. I thought your “best un-beef burger” was a cop-out. What is your favorite burger? Do you have one? Just cough it up, already!
Platt: My favorite burger is Shake Shack. No contest.
Ozersky: What about the contest for best ramen? Was your winner, Setagaya, neck and neck with Momofuku?
Platt: Well, Momofuku isn't really a ramen bar, is it. Setagaya's the real thing, straight from Tokyo, complete with towel-headed ramen ninjas behind the bar, and legions of faithful ramen geeks slurping down bowls of that delicious "shio ramen."
Ozersky: But does that mean their soup is better? What do I care if it's more authentic?
Platt: Yes, that means the broth is better. What do you know about ramen, Mr. Pork Chop?!?
Ozersky: What do you think the broth is made of? Speaking of pork, I had to wonder at you picking Adour. In a city with so much great bacon, sausage, char siu, chops, and all the rest, I find it hard to believe that ultrarefined number there could be the best.
Platt: It's a matter of taste, Cutty! The Adour dish combines all the thing you pork fiends crave: artisanal flavor, good old-time fattiness (there's a little stamp of candied belly on the side), and a wheel of loose, handmade boudin noir thrown in.
Ozersky: I'm glad I didn't have to write that one. I think my brain would have exploded. I'm glad, too, that I didn't have to do the lasagne category. Marco's is fantastic, but so is the mushroom-driven version at Fiamma.
Platt: I didn't like the Fiamma lasagne much. I dimly recall it being sludgy and brown and weirdly sweet. In my humble opinion, the lasagne verdi at Insieme is a more faithful gourmet iteration of this great family dish.
Ozersky: What about the part where you pick your favorite new restaurant? Did you and Gail and the Robs divvy that up? Was Dovetail your real pick, or did you cede another place to one of them?
Platt: It does sound like we divvied them up, but Dovetail was my real pick. I liked the unlikely location, and the range of the cooking. Also it's the last good restaurant I've dined at. After a month or two my memory fades.
Most Viewed Stories
The Polo Bar Runs New York’s Toughest (and Most Irritating) Door Policy
Ben McKenzie Makes Sure to Eat a Bagel at Least Once a Month
Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Hidden Pizza, Excellent Ramen, and Lots More
A Proposed New Health Department Rule Could Ruin New York’s Sushi Scene
Uma Thurman and Meg Ryan Dine at Upland; Bloomberg Eats Pre-Storm Pizza
Here Are All 24 Bon-Bon Flavors From NYC’s Newest Chocolate SensationAll openings »
B. Smith Has Closed Her Last Remaining Restaurant After 28 YearsAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Stories Elsewhere You Might Like
10 Movies That Should Be Remade with Female Leads
Well + Good
Gwyneth recommends steam cleaning your vagina: What you need to know
Shaken vs. Stirred
The Best New Supermarket Snacks of 2015 (So Far)
powered by PubExchange
Latest News on Grub StreetWings, Beer, Spoodles: How a Buffalo Wild Wings Preps for Super Bowl Sunday
40,000 wings, a couple hundred gallons of sauce, 100 more gallons of blue cheese and ranch, and a thing that's not quite a spoon, not quite a ladle.A Grub Street Editor Says Good-bye
It's time to make the Shmoo Donuts, so to speak.Hershey’s Looks Beyond Chocolate As Threats to Its Business Pile Up
This includes a buying a jerky company.Starbucks Rolls Out Seahawks-Themed Frappuccinos
Your move, Dunkaccinos.Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Hidden Pizza, Excellent Ramen, and Lots More
Find out where to eat in our weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.America Prepares to Go Full Shack
Danny Meyer is killing it even more than usual these days.The Polo Bar Runs New York’s Toughest (and Most Irritating) Door Policy
It's like a nightclub for 'Real Housewives' rejects.A Proposed New Health Department Rule Could Ruin New York’s Sushi Scene
Changes to the code will require fish served raw to be frozen beforehand.Uma Thurman and Meg Ryan Dine at Upland; Bloomberg Eats Pre-Storm Pizza
This week's Celebrity Settings.Ben McKenzie Makes Sure to Eat a Bagel at Least Once a Month
"There's such a wide variety of foods in New York. It's more of an epicurean kind of place than L.A. People here indulge. I love it.."
Don't even ask about Dunkin' Donuts and their foam cups.Danny Meyer Could Make $140 Million From Shake Shack’s IPO
More, if the share prices keep rising.Taco Bell Joins the Fight to Make the Much-Wanted Taco Emoji Real
The petition has 25,000 signatures.This Is a Real Line to Get Into Burger King
Just wait until France gets its first Shake Shack.Congress Moves to Create a Single Food-Safety Super-Agency From FDA and USDA Components
Lawmakers say consolidation would make it easier to prevent foodborne illness.Open Calls for Top Chef Season 13 Begin Next Week
Attention, all you people with ace brunoise game.McDonald’s Finally Ousted Its Struggling CEO
Sales have been on the decline for eight consecutive months.Fat, Chants: A Humane Evening of Protesting Foie Gras in L.A.
Checking in with animal-rights advocates outside one of Santa Monica's most lauded restaurants.People Waited for 3 Hours to Eat at Vegas’s First White Castle
Serious excitement for the first location out West.Living Near a Starbucks Might Double Your Home’s Value
The "Starbucks Effect" is very real, say the authors of a new book.
"I always feel like there's this moment of shock. Like, You? You look so young, you seem so young!"East Village Cheese May Get Swallowed Up by Duane Reade [Updated]
Its neighbors are all being evicted.Team USA Takes Silver for the First Time Ever at the Bocuse d’Or 2015
The closest we had gotten previously was sixth place.Ikea’s New Meatballs Will Be Vegan After All
The company got a raft of petitions.Watch Jimmy Kimmel Give People ‘Cold-Pressed Juice’ Made From Skittles
"Are you tasting the kale, obviously?"Taco Bell’s New Cinnabon Coffee Needs to Be the End of This Nonsense
Spoiler alert: It won't be.Critic Jonathan Gold on Anonymity, His New Film, and Where to Find Good Pizza in L.A.
"Can you imagine me being Guy Fieri?"See Rôtisserie Georgette’s Lavishly Accessorized, Spiked Chocolat Chaud
Rather dark with a bittersweet edge and served with panache.You Can Get a Whole Roasted Pig Delivered on Super Bowl Sunday
This is how Daniel Boulud does game day.Hershey’s Successfully Blocks British Chocolate Imports, and Now Must Face the Fierce Backlash
Those Flake bar fanatics are not happy at all.
That's 30 million more than last year.Newcastle Crowd-Sourced a Ridiculous 37-Brand Super Bowl Ad
Good luck remembering any of them.Japan’s Chile-Spiked Ramen Chain Ichiran Is Really, Finally Opening in New York
Get ready to slurp tonkotsu in the privacy of your own partitioned seating, for real this time.Modern Matcha: Where to Drink (and Eat) New York’s Latest Obsession
Lattes, cocktails, pastries, and more.Serious Pastry Chefs Taste-Test the New Red Velvet Oreos
"I thought they'd be redder."Here’s a New Craft Beer That Smells Just Like Pot
"It should hit you right in the face, as soon as you smell the beer."Real-Estate Deal Might Not Bode Well for Barbuto
A lot has changed on Washington Street in the last 12 years.Blizzard Cuisine: 12 Recipes to Make With the Random Stuff in Your Pantry
How about some Danish bread-and-beer porridge?Restaurant Owner Defends American Sniper by Banning Seth Rogen and Michael Moore
Because those guys really want to visit his steakhouse.Three-Michelin-Starred Chef Eneko Atxa Will Cook in New York Next Month
Good news for people who love oysters with "algae foam."
Michel Nischan is the Humanitarian of the Year.Anheuser-Busch Swallows Up Another Revered Craft Brewery
Elysian Brewing may have to replace its "Corporate Beer Still Sucks" tagline.Here Are All 24 Bon-Bon Flavors From NYC’s Newest Chocolate Sensation
Raspberry rose, sesame and passion fruit, bourbon maple pecan, and more.Top Chef Contestant Says He Was Put on Three-Day Involuntary Psych Hold
"I've been destroyed by the experience."French Judge Rules It’s Not Okay to Name Your Kid ‘Nutella’
Too much "mockery or disobliging remarks" is at stake.KFC’s Double Down Hot Dog Is Very Real
They're only selling 100 of them.Pulitzer Prize–Winning Food Critic Jonathan Gold Abandons ‘Anonymity’
"If chefs truly can cook better when they know a critic is in the house, then restaurants without an early warning system are at a permanent disadvantage."The 9 Best New Soups to Try Right Now
They’ll fortify you until the spring thaw.New Yorkers Are Either Really Sad, or Really Happy, About Continental’s Demise
The dive bar's bankruptcy has stirred up some mixed emotions.Harvard Has Secretly Become One of Southern California’s Biggest Grape Growers
Its 10,000 acres put it among the top 20 largest in Paso Robles.