It's no surprise that the author of a cookbook called Italian, My Way would be opinionated about meatballs; Jonathan Waxman, chef-owner of Barbuto, is certainly that. Having noted the explosion of meaty orbs in recent years, we enlisted Waxman to taste-test some notable balls around town, at Corsino, Frankie's 570 Spuntino, Co., Donatella, the Meatball Shop, and the little owl. Though Waxman doesn't keep meatballs on Barbuto's regular menu ("It's a little bit clich"), he'll occasionally serve them as a special "maybe once a month; it doesn't have to be the same mixture all the time." And as we toured, Waxman proved his meatball connoisseurship: "The marriage of the sauce and the meatball is the most important thing, because it really is a braised dish, almost a stew," he explained. "A meatball sounds simple," he continued, "but then you get into the science of it." To Waxman, that means flavor, moisture, how it's cooked, and yes, size matters, too: "Golf ball is the perfect size." We asked Waxman to rate the various balls on a scale of one to five, and while "we never found our five" (as the toque lamented), we did have a clear winner. See our slideshow to learn which ball prevailed.
Corsino: Heritage brisket meatballs, $15
The flavor's good. It's a little dry, a little on the dense side. I don't think it has that fluffiness. They could be cooked a little better. It's well represented, but the rocket ship hasn't taken off.
TOTAL POINTS: 3
Co.: Meatballs, $10
"Value-wise, they're kind of a 4, but everything else is a 3.5. I don't love the sauce; it's a little soupy. I like the size of these — these are a little bit more Northern Italian; they're really tender. [The garlic] is something I'd detract points on. And you have a bread guy, you get a lot of bread."
TOTAL POINTS: 3.5
The Meatball Shop: Classic beef meatballs in classic tomato sauce, $7
"These are very good. I like the size; they don't feel like they're perfectly round. They're not trying to be fancy. They're not trying to reinvent the wheel. They get kudos for value. The sauce is the least attractive part."
TOTAL POINTS: 4
Donatella: Spicy Meatballs, $13
"Good aroma. This is the kind of size I love the most. These are very good; I like the spice. It has a silkiness I like, but I want the silkiness coupled with more meaty flavor. This seems very machine-made."
TOTAL POINTS: 4
Frankie's 570 Spuntino: Meatballs with pine nuts and raisins, $12
"These are definitely saucy balls ... A little too much raw garlic for me. The sauce is good. The meatballs are tender, they have more of a homemade feel. I think they could be a little smaller, but I know what they're going for."
TOTAL POINTS: 4
Most Viewed Stories
The 12 Best Garlicky Dishes in New York Right Now
The 10 Best Lines From Jay Rayner’s Brutal Steakhouse Takedown
French Bakery Maman Sells NYC’s Most Impressive New Chocolate-Chip Cookie
Yotam Ottolenghi on Instant Ramen, Plenty More, and His Secret Candy Stash
Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Take Root, Marta, and More
What to Eat at Cotenna, the New Italian Restaurant Inside the ’ino SpaceAll openings »
The Marrow Will Close Tomorrow NightAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Latest News on Grub StreetHere’s an Entire Japanese New Year’s Feast That Comes in a Pokemon Ball
Choose this Poké Ball and get 26 traditional osechi dishes for $136.Brave Chili’s Cook Vows to Capitalize on Shirtless Viral Photo Shoot That Got Him Fired
"Trust and believe I'm capitalizing."First Look at Empellon al Pastor, Now Open in the East Village
Alex Stupak has flung open the doors of his much-anticipated bar-tortilleria in the East Village.Eataly’s Wine Shop Makes a Triumphant Return
The celebration includes free glasses of sparkling wine tonight.The Race to Create America’s Premier Carbonated Cold Brew
The Austin-based company Coffer has already attracted attention from coffee industry heavyweights.Ben & Jerry’s Defends Its ‘Hazed & Confused’ Ice Cream
The company told angry parents nothing about it "condoned hazing, supported hazing, or even inferred hazing."Yotam Ottolenghi on Instant Ramen, Plenty More, and His Secret Candy Stash
"People are becoming quite precious about what they eat."New York Taste Returns Next Month
Our annual culinary extravaganza happens November 10 with more than 40 of New York's best chefs and restaurants.The 10 Best Lines From Jay Rayner’s Brutal Steakhouse Takedown
"The most unintentionally funny restaurant to open in London in a very long time."Danny Meyer’s Untitled at the Whitney Closed in Advance of Its Move Downtown
The Breuer building is closed, but the huckleberry pancakes will be back in May of 2015.
Now is not the time to worry about minty-fresh breath.A New Study Shows That Calorie Counts on Menus Don’t Do Much at All
"People don't really understand what it means to say a typical soda has 250 calories," says a researcher who thinks the number-board system of listing calorie counts is not effective.New York Attorney General Sues Papa John's Franchisee for Labor Violations
A franchisee with four Manhattan locations not only allegedly cheated its employees out of hourly wages, it forced them to pay for their own bicycles, helmets, safety gear.Some Poor Waitress Had to Tell President Obama That His Credit Card Was Declined
"Turns out I guess I don't use it enough."Starbucks Gets One Step Closer to Having Your Drinks Ready the Moment You Arrive
It won't be long before the Starbucks app knows everything about you, but at least your drink will be hot when you get these.Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Take Root, Marta, and More
Find out where to eat in Grub Street's weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.French Bakery Maman Sells NYC’s Most Impressive New Chocolate-Chip Cookie
It's made by a Michelin-starred chef.Garrett Oliver to David Chang: Shut Up About Crappy Beer Already
"Dear Dave, I'm a little worried about you."Kate Mara Grabs Coffee at La Colombe; Mindy Kaling and Malcolm Gladwell Party at the Standard
This week's Celebrity Settings.Jamie Oliver Faces Backlash After Hiring a Convicted Rapist
The celebrity chef's team defends their decision, saying that David Mason served his time and deserves a shot at rehabilitating his life.
It may be British, but there is lox on the bagels.Chef Sean Brock Eats Bologna in Nashville and Blood Sausage in New York
"I got my regular order: meatloaf with Creole sauce, mashed potatoes, green beans, fried green tomatoes, white beans, corn pudding, and sweet tea."A Lot of People Were Outraged by Michael Ruhlman’s Response to a ‘Shrill’ Times Essay
"I like girls in kitchen a lot: it does bring that testosterone level down a little bit, it makes it not so aggressive," a British chef said recently.Pharrell Williams’s Ubiquity Now Extends to Fancy French Macarons
He and Ladurée have made peanut-butter and cola macarons.Eating Vegan Ice Cream With Jason Schwartzman and Director Alex Ross Perry
"It's hard for me to relate to people who don't have a huge sweet tooth."This Coffee-Making Robot Is the World's Worst Barista
It can whip up a Nespresso in about three minutes.Animal Rights Group Blasts Starbucks for Using Eggs From ‘Cruel Farms’
Despite claims that they're "ethically purchased and responsibly produced."Thug Kitchen Is Officially a Best Seller
It's also No. 1 on Amazon's best seller list of vegan cookbooks.11 Places to Find Fancy Hummus
Truffle hummus at Claudette, burnt-jalapeño hummus at Empéllon Cocina, and more.Mayor de Blasio Is Still Quietly Trying to Ban Your Soda
He's holding "high-level meetings" on "the best way to reach that goal."
The burgers all look pretty horrible to begin with; at least the month-old ones have penicillin.Saltie Stays Open Late to Morph Into Mr. Curry
Chips and curry sauce, naan, and rice and pickle are on the menu.Against All Reasonable Odds, a Man Insists This Giant Mouse Was in His McDonald’s Coffee
It was a total "surprise" when he took the lid off.19 Defining Moments in the History of Yogurt
Congratulations, New York, you have a new state snack.Here’s a Start-up That Promises to ‘Age’ Whiskey Instantly
Why put the whiskey into the barrel when you can put the barrel into the whiskey?‘Veggie-Forward’ Williamsburg Pop-Up Chez José Is Reborn As Brick-and-Mortar Semilla
Chef José Ramírez-Ruiz, who has worked at Per Se and Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare, will serve a $75 prix-fixe at his restaurant's 18-seat U-shaped bar.Restaurant’s Waitstaff Quits Midday, Alleging Racism and Way Too Many Flying Bugs
He allegedly fired people for being black, old, or fat.Why James Oseland Left Saveur to Clean Chicken Coops
"I closed all the blinds in the apartment, turned off the TV, lit a couple candles ... "The NYPD Thinks a Yelper May Have Smoke-Bombed Bar Pitti
"They're looking for stuff like, 'This place sucks and I'm going to blow this f--king place up.'"Keith McNally Swears Pastis Will Reopen in the Meatpacking District in 2016
The restaurateur says he's got a location on Gansevoort Street.
Brooklyn's Take Root is "an oasis of passion, a crack in the rock of a cynical world."Meet the Creative Genius Who Turns Starbucks Cups Into Art
His masterworks morph the Siren into Colonel Sanders, a Lego minifigurine, and PSY.Colors Comes Back to Life As a Gluten-Free, Living-Wage-Paying Restaurant
The cooperative East Village restaurant is serving "upscale comfort food."Mario Borgatti, the Bronx’s Pasta Patriarch, Has Died
Borgatti was born in 1917 and was just 17 when his parents opened up shop on East 187th Street in 1935.Here’s a Guy Who’s Banned From Every Bar and Restaurant in London
35,000 establishments he cannot enter — a citywide first.Will Letter for Lunch: One Woman’s Plan to Hand-Write Menus in Exchange for Food
"I have a service and I'm hungry."Rick Bayless Will Cook in New York With Alex Stupak Next Month
The chefs will team up for one night only.Here’s What It Looks Like When Eric Wareheim Makes a Cookbook Trailer
It's like a gastrique made of punk, gluten, and early 1990s public-access TV.What to Eat at King Bee, a New ‘Acadian-Inspired’ Restaurant in the East Village
Say what?Perdue Chicken Will Remove ‘Humanely Raised’ From Its Label to Settle Two Lawsuits
The Humane Society had claimed it "slapped stickers on," hoping consumers "won't know the difference."