If there's one thing New York is not short on, it's sandwiches. From the bodega across the street to the fancy sandwiches peppering the boroughs, it seems like we have it all. However, one can never have too many sandwiches, so a couple of national chains have moved on in to join the city's sandwich scene. Earl of Sandwich and Potbelly's both arrived in New York this summer and have already started expanding. It's easy to see why they're doing well. But are they any good? We decided we needed to grab a man who knew his way around a sandwich and have him decide. Enter No. 7 Sub's Tyler Kord, the man who has even managed to elevate humble bologna into a special meal between bread. We set out with Tyler, and an open mind, to see if the featured sandwiches at these chains are worthy of your lunchtime dollars.
Earl of Sandwich: The Full Montagu
Roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, Cheddar, lettuce, roma tomato, and "the Earl's mustard sauce."
Tyler came into the first Earl sandwich with high hopes after reading the description: "That sounds like a party. A sandwich party." He was pleased with the amount of meat included for the $5.99 price tag, but found that even with all those ingredients, it basically tasted like a hot dog. A "salty as balls" hot dog.
Earl of Sandwich: Italian
Salami, capicola, roasted ham, mortadella, mozzarella, roma tomato, and "zesty Italian dressing."
Earl's Italian tasted overwhelmingly of pepperoni, despite pepperoni not being an ingredient in the sandwich. "It tastes like a good slice of pepperoni pizza, crossed with a Hot Pocket. In a good way." Tyler found the bread portion "inoffensive, which in sandwiches is a good thing."
Earl of Sandwich: The Original 1762
Roast beef, Cheddar, and "creamy horseradish sauce."
This was the clear winner of the three Earl's sandwiches we tried. "I can actually tell what I'm eating!" Tyler said. "It tastes like roast beef, which is nice." It had an "Arby's flavor profile" (a good thing, as Tyler loves Arby's), but the meat was clearly beef, and not meat-flavored "sawdust, like at Arby's." However, the meat had some rainbow action on it, which is nice in the sky but not what you want to see on your beef.
Potbelly: Roast Beef
"Thin-sliced" beef and provolone.
Potbelly's roast beef disappointed as soon as it was unwrapped, and made it clear why the chain offers an "extra meat" option — the sandwich had just an ounce of roast beef on it (for comparison, a bodega sandwich usually has three or four ounces). It also had no taste. "This could literally be any protein. It could even be tofu, or seitan to get the texture right." The lack of flavor turned out to be what Tyler found most surprising, explaining that with all the chemicals at the disposal of factory farms, they could make their products taste like "unicorn meat" if they wanted to. Sadly, there were no unicorn horns on display at Potbelly.
Potbelly: The Italian
Capicola, mortadella, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese.
Potbelly's Italian, unlike Earl's, did not taste solely of pepperoni. "It tastes the most like what you could get at a bodega, which is the ultimate sandwich in a way. It's kind of the standard." It definitely didn't need a purchase of extra meat; however, there was so much grease that eating more than a bite or two seemed like too much. "I'd pay extra to not eat that," Kord told us. A shame, because this would have been the winning Potbelly sandwich if not for the explosion of oil.
Potbelly: A Wreck
Salami, roast beef, turkey, ham, and Swiss cheese.
Another signature sandwich, another sandwich that tasted like a hot dog. Unfortunate, because this was the one we had heard the best things about from Midwestern friends. "This tastes like something people in the Midwest would love, but we live in New York," responded Tyler. The Wreck also suffered from lack of meat, but was the tastiest of the Potbelly bunch.
Most Viewed Stories
Above the Fray: How Restaurants Become Impervious to Criticism
Burrata Everywhere: 24 Places to Eat Everyone’s Favorite Menu Item
World Decides Deep-Fried Candy Corn Is One Step Too Far
First Look at Empellon al Pastor, Now Open in the East Village
McDonald’s Figures Out That People Sort of Hate Going to McDonald’s
What to Eat at Cosme, New York’s Next Mexican BlockbusterAll openings »
The Marrow Will Close Tomorrow NightAll closings »
Search by name
Or, search by
Latest News on Grub StreetHere Are the 2015 Michelin Stars for San Francisco; Benu and Saison Both Get Major Upgrades
Chefs Corey Lee and Joshua Skenes join the three-star club.Restaurant Posts Somber ‘Obituary’ After Upstairs Neighbor Kills the Business
"Cause of death: The HMO owner who did not fix a leak."McDonald’s Figures Out That People Sort of Hate Going to McDonald’s
The megachain's profits take a dive while Chipotle just keeps on killing it.A Man Claims His Golden Corral Chili Contained a Snaggletoothed Rat Head
"I was like, 'Maybe, you know, sometimes you get a hard bean inside.'"Burrata Everywhere: 24 Places to Eat Everyone’s Favorite Menu Item
It's the new bacon.Cappuccino Chips Are, Thankfully, No Longer Happening
Wasabi Ginger has won Lay's "Do Us a Flavor" contest in an apparent landslide, and no one is demanding a recall.L.A.’s Top Round Roast Beef Plans to Open in NYC, and Everywhere Else
Bring on the Beef on Wecks, Provel-topped steak sandwiches, and gravy-topped dirty fries.World Decides Deep-Fried Candy Corn Is One Step Too Far
"Those four words in THAT order? NAW."Above the Fray: How Restaurants Become Impervious to Criticism
To be above a certain threshold is to enter a kind of realm of immortality and myth, immune to the random quibbles of everyday life.Here’s an Entire Japanese New Year’s Feast That Comes in a Pokemon Ball
Choose this Poké Ball and get 26 traditional osechi dishes for $136.
"Trust and believe I'm capitalizing."First Look at Empellon al Pastor, Now Open in the East Village
Alex Stupak has flung open the doors of his much-anticipated bar-tortilleria in the East Village.Eataly’s Wine Shop Makes a Triumphant Return
The celebration includes free glasses of sparkling wine tonight.The Race to Create America’s Premier Carbonated Cold Brew
The Austin-based company Coffer has already attracted attention from coffee industry heavyweights.Ben & Jerry’s Defends Its ‘Hazed & Confused’ Ice Cream
The company told angry parents nothing about it "condoned hazing, supported hazing, or even inferred hazing."Yotam Ottolenghi on Instant Ramen, Plenty More, and His Secret Candy Stash
"People are becoming quite precious about what they eat."New York Taste Returns Next Month
Our annual culinary extravaganza happens November 10 with more than 40 of New York's best chefs and restaurants.The 10 Best Lines From Jay Rayner’s Brutal Steakhouse Takedown
"The most unintentionally funny restaurant to open in London in a very long time."Danny Meyer’s Untitled at the Whitney Closed in Advance of Its Move Downtown
The Breuer building is closed, but the huckleberry pancakes will be back in May of 2015.The 12 Best Garlicky Dishes in New York Right Now
Now is not the time to worry about minty-fresh breath.
"People don't really understand what it means to say a typical soda has 250 calories," says a researcher who thinks the number-board system of listing calorie counts is not effective.New York Attorney General Sues Papa John's Franchisee for Labor Violations
A franchisee with four Manhattan locations not only allegedly cheated its employees out of hourly wages, it forced them to pay for their own bicycles, helmets, safety gear.Some Poor Waitress Had to Tell President Obama That His Credit Card Was Declined
"Turns out I guess I don't use it enough."Starbucks Gets One Step Closer to Having Your Drinks Ready the Moment You Arrive
It won't be long before the Starbucks app knows everything about you, but at least your drink will be hot when you get these.Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Take Root, Marta, and More
Find out where to eat in Grub Street's weekly ranking of the city's most-buzzed-about restaurants.French Bakery Maman Sells NYC’s Most Impressive New Chocolate-Chip Cookie
It's made by a Michelin-starred chef.Garrett Oliver to David Chang: Shut Up About Crappy Beer Already
"Dear Dave, I'm a little worried about you."Kate Mara Grabs Coffee at La Colombe; Mindy Kaling and Malcolm Gladwell Party at the Standard
This week's Celebrity Settings.Jamie Oliver Faces Backlash After Hiring a Convicted Rapist
The celebrity chef's team defends their decision, saying that David Mason served his time and deserves a shot at rehabilitating his life.Introducing Delancey & Co, London’s First Lower East SideThemed Takeout Shop
It may be British, but there is lox on the bagels.
"I got my regular order: meatloaf with Creole sauce, mashed potatoes, green beans, fried green tomatoes, white beans, corn pudding, and sweet tea."A Lot of People Were Outraged by Michael Ruhlman’s Response to a ‘Shrill’ Times Essay
"I like girls in kitchen a lot: it does bring that testosterone level down a little bit, it makes it not so aggressive," a British chef said recently.Pharrell Williams’s Ubiquity Now Extends to Fancy French Macarons
He and Ladurée have made peanut-butter and cola macarons.Eating Vegan Ice Cream With Jason Schwartzman and Director Alex Ross Perry
"It's hard for me to relate to people who don't have a huge sweet tooth."This Coffee-Making Robot Is the World's Worst Barista
It can whip up a Nespresso in about three minutes.Animal Rights Group Blasts Starbucks for Using Eggs From ‘Cruel Farms’
Despite claims that they're "ethically purchased and responsibly produced."Thug Kitchen Is Officially a Best Seller
It's also No. 1 on Amazon's best seller list of vegan cookbooks.11 Places to Find Fancy Hummus
Truffle hummus at Claudette, burnt-jalapeño hummus at Empéllon Cocina, and more.Mayor de Blasio Is Still Quietly Trying to Ban Your Soda
He's holding "high-level meetings" on "the best way to reach that goal."See How 7 Fast-Food Burgers Rot (or Don’t) Over Time
The burgers all look pretty horrible to begin with; at least the month-old ones have penicillin.
Chips and curry sauce, naan, and rice and pickle are on the menu.Against All Reasonable Odds, a Man Insists This Giant Mouse Was in His McDonald’s Coffee
It was a total "surprise" when he took the lid off.19 Defining Moments in the History of Yogurt
Congratulations, New York, you have a new state snack.Here’s a Start-up That Promises to ‘Age’ Whiskey Instantly
Why put the whiskey into the barrel when you can put the barrel into the whiskey?‘Veggie-Forward’ Williamsburg Pop-Up Chez José Is Reborn As Brick-and-Mortar Semilla
Chef José Ramírez-Ruiz, who has worked at Per Se and Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare, will serve a $75 prix-fixe at his restaurant's 18-seat U-shaped bar.Restaurant’s Waitstaff Quits Midday, Alleging Racism and Way Too Many Flying Bugs
He allegedly fired people for being black, old, or fat.Why James Oseland Left Saveur to Clean Chicken Coops
"I closed all the blinds in the apartment, turned off the TV, lit a couple candles ... "The NYPD Thinks a Yelper May Have Smoke-Bombed Bar Pitti
"They're looking for stuff like, 'This place sucks and I'm going to blow this f--king place up.'"Keith McNally Swears Pastis Will Reopen in the Meatpacking District in 2016
The restaurateur says he's got a location on Gansevoort Street.Esquire Names America’s Best New Restaurants for 2014
Brooklyn's Take Root is "an oasis of passion, a crack in the rock of a cynical world."